News

Counterpoint: Obama takes the hard, high road

Saturday, March 29, 2008

By Grace Hammond

Jackson Hole, Wyoming - Race in America is anything but black and white.

Sen. Barack Obama took a chance on the American people last week with “A More Perfect Union,” a speech that addressed not only his relationship with the controversial Rev. Jeremiah Wright but the past, present and future of race relations in this country. The blustering, name-calling responses of some pundits prove the importance of this speech and the fact that racism remains alive and well in this country.

Obama’s message of hope and reconciliation contained uncomfortable truths for most, if not all, listeners. He did not excuse any group of participation in the racial divide: not Democrats or Republicans, nor Rev. Wright or the black community. 

He “condemned, in unequivocal terms” Wright’s statements, which he said “denigrate both the greatness and the goodness of our nation.” However, he chose to ‘hate the sin, not the sinner,’ a nuanced, carefully-explained decision that left critics who were out for blood unsatisfied.

 “[Wright] contains within him the contradictions – the good and the bad – of the community that he has served diligently for so man
y years,” Obama said.
Obama gave Americans something they haven’t seen on the political landscape for quite some time: a speech that was more honest than it was a “good idea.” After seven years with an administration that put “you’re either for us or against us” into disastrous effect, Obama approached a nation trained to think in black and white and asked them to consider shades of gray.

If our country did not suffer from the racial problems Obama spoke of, its people could have listened - truly listened - believing, at very least, that there is something to be learned about the contemporary black experience from a black man. To some, the speech represented food for thought; to others, it represented a threat to the Republic.

To dismiss this speech as political posturing is to deny and invalidate experiences that are different from one’s own. It is to exhibit the kind of racism that believes that because slavery has been abolished, white people shouldn’t have to hear about it, and that to discuss racism in any of its forms is to whine. “After all,” this mentality says, “We gave you freedom, the right to vote and Martin Luther King Day. Get over it.”

In this mentality, there can be no progress, because there is no more progress to be made.

This mentality points to so-called ‘reverse racism’ as proof that white people are the victims now - and if they are the victims, blacks are not, they cannot be. That is why the snippets that we’ve seen of Rev. Wright’s sermons were met with such glee, self-righteousness, and an air of “gotcha!” The buzzards that have circled Obama and Wright reveal fear and ignorance.

It is folly to believe that a nation that clings to denial can be united or that the politics of race are as simple as the politics on a playground, where everything is black or white, good or bad. Rather than providing the American people with a few soundbites to address their questions, or simply ignoring those who would indict him for another man’s words, Obama placed his vision for the nation above his political aspirations and spoke to Americans on the level. It’s something I could get used to.
PERMALINK:
Counterpoint: Obama takes the hard, high road | Planet JH News Article: General News

Reader Comments

Excellent, well thought out and well written article. Thank you for sharing your thoughts and know that I share in them.
Dani girl

OBAMA IS UNELECTABLE IN GENERAL ELECTION. With each new utterance on the topic of Reverend Wright, Barack Obama seems to confirm his own moral obliviousness. Worse yet, he seems to have disdain for those who are troubled by his own unwillingness to break with Wright. But it gets worse. Obama insists Wright is “a brilliant man who was still stuck in a time warp.” So brilliant, apparently, that he has uncovered the plot by white America to kill African Americans and so insightful as to perceive the 9/11 attacks as caused by America’s own terrorism. Then there was his discerning observation that Israel is a “dirty” word. And after all this, still Wright, in Obama’s eyes, is brilliant. This, we are told by the legions of Obamaphiles, is not supposed to affect voters’ view of Obama’s judgment. perhaps they are just embarrassed to tell pollsters they are privately offended. But in a general election contest this is not going to go unnoticed, we will see Republicans and many independents are irked by this moral obtuseness. Do not believe what you see on CNN or Hardball. Easy to see already see Republican attack ads against Obama, especially since he just came out again yesterday defending Wrights hateful Racism and attacks on white America. Is he an idiot? First open with videos of racist wife, Michelle, saying she was proud of America "for the first time" because of her husband's presidential candidacy, next Obama explaining that he doesn't wear an American flag lapel pin or hold his hands to his heart during the Pledge of Allegiance because it is a "substitute for true patriotism." Then flash a clip of Obama explaining that his Caucasian grandmother was a "typical white person" because she uttered racial epithets and was afraid of black people. Finally, the coup de grace, pictures of Obama's angry, arm-waving preacher blaming the United States for 9/11 and shouting "God Damn America" to the rafters of Chicago's Trinity United Church of Christ and preaching the U.S. government formulated the HIV AIDS virus to commit genocide against blacks. Even though Obama supposedly condemning Wright's shocking verbal assaults against the U.S and White Americans, even last year; Obama was the first to public ally demand Don Imus ouster for making a racially insensitive remark, and Obama continues to support Wrights racism and remains at the church for more than 20 years, he and Michelle obviously feels it’s a good environment to expose his young daughters too. His opinions and issues change with the weather, he is too UNSTABLE and proven he cannot make a decision or stay with one. If that’s not enough, then you start showing his terrible senate voting record, Obama when faced with tough choices always gave in to pressure from the Bush administration or corporate lobbyists, Obama dealings with one of his largest contributors, Exelon, a big nuclear power company and the deals he cut behind closed doors to protect them from full disclosure in the nuclear industry. Obamas record shows he infact did support the war when he got to the senate, voted twice against bringing America's troops back home. He voted for war appropriations giving our money to Halliburton and Blackwater where Texas woman, was gang-raped by her co-workers at a Halliburton/KBR camp in Baghdad, His latest bit of posturing S 433 allows the Bush Administration to suspend any troop withdrawal, if not suspended, keeps the troops in Iraq for a long time to come, but in his camp stumps touts he wants to bring troops home, but as we have witnessed his recent lies to voters like Canada he cannot be trusted on his word and lastly ALL the corrupt indicted financial backers, like Rezko…Get out of the race Obama you are destroying the democratic party!
jose

Actions Speak Better than Words Before the negative press regarding Mr. Wright, Mr Obama had on numerous occasions declared Mr. Wright as his mentor and spiritual teacher for the past 20 years and even went so far as to include Mr. Wright in his election staff, these are the actions of Mr. Obama. When the press found out about the Hitleresque personality of Mr. Wright, Mr. Obama’s staff writers immediately created a rebuttal of hyperbole that amazingly some people actually believed. It is interesting to note, as soon the public became aware of the Obama/Wright connection, following a phone call to Mr. Wright from Mr. Obama, Mr. Wright was instantly silenced, retired and rewarded with a 1.6 million dollar home. Is there something more we are not supposed to hear from Mr. Wright? And now Mr. Obama says he would distance himself from Mr. Wright because of Mr. Wight hateful message, but what about the other 20 years of Mr. Obama choosing to sit in the pew while Mr. Wright lectured? After 20 years of choosing to listen to Mr. Wright, Mr. Obama has just now come to conclusion that he wouldn’t listen to Mr. Wright starting now? Does Mr. Obama think we are stupid? But regardless of what Mr. Obama’s staff has spun for Mr. Obama’s rebuttal, Mr. Obama cannot retract his clear public proclamation that Mr. Wright has been his mentor and spiritual teacher for over these past 20 YEARS. And that up to recent negative press, Mr. Wright was on Mr. Obama’s Spiritual Advisor Committee campaign team. There is no denying this. And the Obama’s team efforts to downplay the violent rhetoric of Mr. Wright are like trying to make excuses for Hitler. Hitler and Mr. Wright both convey hateful and paranoid messages that should send shivers through the average American. The words of Mr. Wright are violent, hateful and terrifying. This should be a wake up call to every white, Jew, non-Christian, Christians of other faiths, government officials, peoples from other countries and so on. Didn’t Hitler do this too before unleashing his cruelty on the world? If Obama made the choice to listen and learn from this so called spiritual mentor for over 20 years, do you expect me or any other rational being to believe that he wouldn’t be or want to be influenced by his ideas? And what does that say of Mr. Obama’s integrity? Action is the real measure of a person, not their words. We know who Mr. Obama is by his life and choices, not the words he spins. And we can only imagine the amount of hatred Mr. Obama will unleash once he achieves ultimate power. And also consider recent announcement that the chief of the firm involved in the State Department’s passport breach is one of Obama’s adviser. (And why is this not being discussed?) And that Obama has been caught lying about Rezko, regarding the amount of money Rezko gave him, and that Obama still hasn’t come clean about his Rezko land deal. Or further, how Michelle Obama makes a phenomenal $317.000 a month at a hospital in Chicago that is famous for turning away the poor, especially the black poor. And Michelle Obama’s separatist-racist connection to Farrakhan and Chicago's Trinity United Church trumpeting Barack Obama AKA Barack Hussein Obama as the second coming of the messiah. And Michelle Obama’s statement she “has never been proud to be an AMERICAN in her adult life". And for those who don’t know that Obama campaign was originally funded by Islamic Extremist via the Food for Oil Program in Iraq, I suggest you read the following article: http://www.americanthinker.com/2008/03/obamas_iraqi_oil_for_food_conn.html If Obama were to become president, what would stop Mr. Obama from appointing Mr. Wright to his cabinet? And after Mr. Wright’s appointment, if anyone complained no doubt they would be called racist. And it seems as if this strategy - that it is racist to criticize a black man - is already in effect as Mr. Obama can do anything corrupt with minimal impunity by the public or the press. But if Hillary so much as sneezes, she is taken through the laundry and hung out to dry and then beaten some more. Such an obvious bias treatment towards Mr. Obama because of his race is racial discrimination. And I believe another reason why Mrs. Clinton is unfairly criticized to such an extreme is because a handful of powerful men in the media can’t stand the idea of a woman for president – likely a libido thing. We should have as our country’s leader someone with wisdom and knowledge, whose goal is the selfless betterment of the world. We should not elect someone with a personal agenda for personal power or select them because of the fashionably of their race or the preference for a gender. With all the red lights in Mr. Obama’s resume, and all the hyperbole that he spins that keeps us from knowing the real Mr. Obama, are you sure this is the person best to lead our country? Should we gamble away the American future to a man who associates with and is taught by men who hate this country and its people?
Richard Allen

Richard Allen, What your problem? You are currently posting all your lies everywhere. Why is that? Here is one of your lies below: You said this: " Do not believe what you see on CNN or Hardball. Easy to see already see Republican attack ads against Obama, especially since he just came out again yesterday defending Wrights hateful Racism and attacks on white America" My response to you is: Do you know the difference between hate and anger?!?! Do you understand the difference between white american and usa government? Rev. Wright is not preaching hatred against white people, rather anger against the usa government which is killing people all over the world, from Iraq to Afghanistan, and so on
eddie

It's sad how delusional people are about "America" being some Holy nation populated and governed by angelic beings. The good ole USA has "officially" been hijacked by multi-national corporations and their profiteering ways. People in this nation are to be oppressed and exploited, plain and simple. Capitalism, for the majority, has become a new form of enslavement. Why can't America evolve like the rest of the modern world? Because it's not good for business, thats why. There's no logic to the Afghan or Iraq invasion, just oil interests. 9/11 was a Bush/Bin Laden collaboration to create the excuse to wage a profit driven war. When you look at all the atrocities that the US Govt. is directly responsible for over the last 100 years it is clear that a good "god damn america" rabble rousing is desperately needed. "Americas chickens are coming home to roust" and its about time!! Rev. Whites views may be frightening to people, but I think its because he's speaking the truth. So many americans lack the spinal column to deal with reality of our horrific history. Ignorance isn't bliss, its a diss.
Joshua Doolittle

BO is a politician just like the rest of 'em. No better & no worse than an average politician. He reminds me of Jimmy Carter and, if elected, I don't expect great things to happen to American politics or the republic.
eyeson jackson

Maybe if the MSM stuck to vetting the veracity of controversial claims, instead of playing some merely for their sensational ratings, the American people, who so often suffer from historical amnesia, would be better informed voters and more accountable citizens. Rev. Wright made 3 central claims in the oft-repeated video clips of his now famous sermon(s): 1) Blowback from America's foreign policy, both overt and covert, contributed to 9/11; 2) The Gov't had a hand in narco-trafficking in the 1980s; 3) The Gov't invented AIDS to harm black people. For claims 1 & 2, there's ample credible evidence to support his assertions. Don't think so? Look no further than: 1) "Charlie Wilson's War"; and 2) the writings of ex-bin Laden CIA analyst Michael F. Scheuer to substantiate the theory that America's involvement with bin Laden's mujahideen in Afghanistan -- to expel the Soviets -- and the U.S. military footprint in Saudi Arabia prior to Sept. 2001 were motivational contributors behind the 9/11 attacks. Everyone now knows that the U.S. military exited stage left from Saudi Arabia after 9/11, right? About Wright's Gov't drug dealing allegations: Have we already forgotten how the illegal Iran-Contra war under Reagan-Bush was funded in part? Re: 1) The findings of the Kerry Commission; 2) Lt. Col. Ollie North's notebooks (www.gwu.edu/~nsarchiv/NSAEBB/NSAEBB2/nsaebb2.htm), and 3) paragraph 623 of CIA inspector General Hinz' report. Finally, on this topic which the media is so loathe to cover in full and without gratuitous self-censorship, there's also the curious memorandum of understanding between Attorney General William French-Smith giving Bill Casey's CIA legal cover regarding its role in trafficking narcotics into the USA. Taken together, these incontrovertible facts shed a bright light on Rev. Wright's charge of official Washington facilitating the illicit drug trade to realize their personal policy ambitions. Regarding Wright's 3rd claim about AIDS being inflicted on blacks? Nope. No proof exists. And justifying Rev. Wright's assertions in the context of the deplorable Tuskegee experiments stretches the logic of relevance to say the least. So, on balance, Rev. Wright is batting .667. On his "GD America" rhetoric? Americans are right to be outraged. Sorry, there's no excuse for that because a man who professes to be of the cloth should not take God's name in vein. However, if one ex-Marine -- like Lt. Col. Oliver North is free to co-ordinate illegal wars and abet international narco-traffickers -- why isn't another ex-Marine -- like Rev. Wright -- free to condemn his fellow serviceman's gross misconduct? Further, had Wright said, "GD Washington!" might that have been more palatable? After all, Dan Abrams' "news show" on MSNBC airs a nightly segment called: "Why Americans hate Washington?" All in all, .667 is a better factual batting average than all of Rev. Wrights' critics and detractors in the so-called mainstream pack of spineless spinning hacks combined. Damn him, perhaps, for confusing anti-American-sounding sentiments with his Constitutional right to denounce bad policies made by provably corrupt officials. How come the MSM or Joe Schloss or The Planet for that matter hasn't bothered to "fact check" any of Rev. Wright's endlessly replayed and sensationalized comments? It's so easy and the provable public record so vast one wonders if they're all more interested in selling papers rather than true news. All of this analysis raises another sound question: Is there a double-standard at play when a relatively marginalized black man, such as Rev. Wright, makes "inflammatory" accusations and the MSM fails to exercise its due diligence but goes to exhaustive lengths to fact-check high-profile Hillary's "Sniper fire" lies and Obama's exaggerated and fond "Camelot" remembrances of his father's passage to America during a speech in Alabama? Lastly, when did "inflammatory" become redefined to mean "untrue" or "false"? I see no connection between the two? Do ANY of YOU? Are you listening, Tucker Carlson or Joe Schloss? We are WATCHING YOU!
Orwell Rolls in His Grave



Leave a Comment


Write a Letter to the Editor
Please limit your letter to 300 words, sign it and give us the name of your town.

Saturday, July 04, 2009


Listen to today's news by Jackson Hole Radio.

TODAY'S EVENTS
Community
Volunteer With Habitat for Humanity
9:00 AM to 4:00 PM
call for location info.
Music
DJ Thunder and Just Kenny
10:00 PM
at 43 North.
Art
Wilson Summer Arts and Crafts Fair
9:00 AM to 1:00 PM
on the Banks of Fish Creek at the Fish Creek Center in Wilson.
Music
Pianist Pam Drews Phillips
7:00 PM to 10:00 PM
in the Granary at Spring Creek Ranch atop East Gros Ventre Butte.
Music
Phil Round
6:30 PM to 9:30 PM
in the lobby of Amangani Hotel.
Music
Lost Traveler
9:00 PM
at the Million Dollar Cowboy Bar.
Film
NWMA Summer Film Series
2:00 PM
National Museum of Wildlife Art
Music
DJ Optimal
11:00 PM
at Cutty's.
Music
Bob Greenspan
6:00 PM to 10:00 PM
in the Four Seasons Lobby Lounge.
Music
Cowboy Logic
8:00 PM to 11:30 PM
at the Silver Dollar Bar in the Wort Hotel.
Music
Revolver
9:00 PM
at the Virginian Saloon.
Music
4th of July Parade
10:30 AM
with the Jackson Hole Community Band from the Rodeo Grounds, up Glenwood St. to Broadway and on past Town Square. The band then plays a full concert on the Town Square starting at 11:30 a.m.
Community
Howdy Pardner Parade
10:30 AM
Teton County Fair Ground to The Town Square.
Community
Jackson Hole Kids Games
11:30 AM
St. Johns Episcopal Church.
Community
Fourth of July Fireworks
12:00 PM
At the base of Snow King and in Teton Village.
Music
God Bless America Festival
12:00 PM
at the Knotty Pine in Victor.
Music
Music in the Hole
3:00 PM
outside at Alpine Field.
Music
Music in the Hole
3:00 PM to 7:30 PM
On Alpine Field
Music
Wounded Knee
6:00 PM to 10:00 PM
on the deck at South Side Pub and Pizza.
Sports & Recreation
Jackson Hole Rodeo
8:00 PM
Rodeo Grounds on W Snow King Ave.
Music
Head for the Hills
9:30 PM
at the Mangy Moose in Teton Village.
Music
Bastard Sons of Johnny Cash
10:00 PM
at the Bull Moose Saloon in Alpine.
View All Events
planet polls
Main Poll
Should local government foster public art initiatives?


Total of voters : 92