News

Ms. Hill's way

Tuesday, September 08, 2009

By Ben Cannon

Jackson Hole, Wyoming - Marion Hill is the name of this community’s most recognizable homeless resident.

“Ms. Hill,” as she prefers, stands out for a number of reasons, including the fact that she has a habit of carrying on a conversation when it appears that the person at the other end isn’t physically present.

She also happens to be one of the very few African American women in Jackson Hole.

Although people occasionally buy her a stay in a motel room, Hill sleeps most nights of the year under a bridge. Her “campsite,” as she calls it, sits along Flat Creek. She has a thick bedroll of blankets laid next to the water, and her belongings arranged in a row of seven or eight plastic bags that neatly line a concrete ledge. It often gets windy down there, and in winter the snow blows in, she told me.

Hill’s story is one that few people here know. Even community aid workers who have had contact with her over the years have been able to piece together only so much of her history. She refuses the kind of help some people think would benefit her most, according to one social worker who asked not to be identified.
But those options – placing
her in a facility that helps people like Hill, reuniting her with family members who can help take care of her– would involve permanently leaving Jackson Hole, and that’s not something she has been willing to do.

“We’ve offered to help get her anywhere,” the social worker said, “but she won’t do it unless it’s a round-trip ticket.”

The inevitable question most have about Hill, is why a person who has to sleep outside would choose to live in a community that sees some of the longest, coldest winters in the continental U.S.?

From Texas to Wyoming
Hill came to Jackson Hole in the early part of this decade, about eight or nine years ago. She grew up in Dallas, she said, and came to Wyoming because of similarities she sees between Wyoming and Texas.

“The history is the same,” she likes to say.

Visiting with her in a cafe the other day, she allowed me to view an old driver’s license that expired in 2002. The woman in the picture is much heavier-looking than the woman who sat next to me. She’s now a diminutive 4 feet, 11 inches.

The address on the license is for an apartment building in east Dallas, not far from an industrial district, according to Google Maps.

Marion Lanelle Hill turned 49 last month.

Because Jackson Hole has very few homeless residents – Hill is perhaps the only non-transient one – and due to the various ways she stands out, Hill has become a fixture of the community to many who observe her and sometimes interact with her.

Recently, Hill has made an early morning visit to Hard Drive Café part of her routine. The restaurant’s owner, Ruth Ann Petroff, said she welcomes her unusual customer.

“I think we all have a curiosity about her story,” Petroff said. “She seems to be homeless and yet she dresses so nicely and is always very polite. It’s not a picture of some indigent person down on her luck. When she talks she seems like she’s educated, and even a little bit worldly.”

Benefactors
On a cold, wet night earlier this summer, Hill was still hanging around the cafe at closing time. Petroff’s husband, Jackson Mayor Mark Barron, drove her to a motel and got her a room for the night.

There are reports that she may have returned there few times since, telling the front desk clerk that a benefactor would pick up the tab.

But because Hill, who sometimes has profane outbursts, lives her life in the public spaces of this usually peaceable community, she sometimes gets into trouble.

She is welcome in most places but has been expelled from others.

One person who has assisted Hill told me she caused one disruption too many at the Teton County Library. A library employee, citing patron confidentiality, wouldn’t comment.

Numerous accounts have her getting kicked out of restaurants and off of public buses.

Yet for the most part, Hill apparently gets by without creating too great a disturbance. A state facility, determining Hill posed no threat to herself or others, said it would not keep her and returned her to Jackson, according to a source.

“If Marion had a cell phone [to her ear], people would think she’s as normal as anyone,” said Roy Meyers, director of the Good Samaritan Mission, which offers shelter, but mainly to homeless men and only on a short-term basis.

Meyers said Hill is always welcome to eat dinner at the Mission, yet she has not decided to do so for some time. “Her schedule doesn’t match up with ours,” he said.

Meyers is one of several people who noted Hill’s sense of style, calling her “the best dressed homeless person in the U.S.” She favors fashionable belts she finds at the thrift stores that accept the clothing vouchers she receives. Hill periodically swaps out old clothes, and always dresses very warmly; it seems she’s never without a jacket.

Ambassador of Flat Creek
Even while Hill often speaks to no one present, and sometimes seems angry at whomever is on the receiving end, she can also be very present and engaging.

I first approached her at her Flat Creek campsite one day, and she remembered my name when I found her again a day or two later. The last time I saw her, on Sunday, she asked when the article would come out.

Hill considers herself deeply Christian. She writes pages upon pages of notes that are presumably related to her role as “an ambassador,” a title she carries for doing God’s work and observing the world around her.

She enjoys the natural beauty of Jackson Hole and the animals, and has the ability to say things that the more poetic souls of this green planet might find profound.

“The mountains are family,” she told me one day during lunch at Subway. “They’re uncles and aunts and sisters and brothers. They are related.”
Only, they’re not our relatives, she explained.

It’s hard to get a handle on why exactly she has decided to stay here the last nine years, but some might like to think her presence could suggest something positive about this community as a whole.

“The story is, how does Jackson Hole treat her?” said Teton County Attorney Steve Weichman, who added he does not believe Hill has posed a significant nuisance to authorities who occasionally deal with her. “It’s like a barometer for our own health. For what it’s worth, she’s chosen Jackson. Maybe that’s a statement that we’re OK.”

Weichman posited there are probably countless unnamed people who have assisted Hill with food, money or simply a ride somewhere.

One person who said he has given Hill a lift told me he believed some family has even offered Hill an unused cabin during some part of winters past.
Hill, however, said that’s not true.

“I wouldn’t know what the inside of a cabin looked like,” she said.

Hill expressed mixed but mostly positive feelings about living here, just like a lot of people I know. She told me she feels most of the residents here are “warm-hearted people,” but added that the community could use “a touch-up.”

“I’m not gonna say there’s attitude, but they [locals] don’t know how to respond necessarily to someone they don’t know,” she said.

Amen, Ms. Hill!, some might add.

At home in the Tetons
Hill traveled throughout most of Wyoming before she arrived in Jackson Hole. She’s moved by one cousin to the Grand Tetons in particular – Devil’s Tower, across the state in northeastern Wyoming.

She said she still has family in Texas, although no one contacted for this story knew how to contact them, or if Hill has any contact with them herself. It appears she does not have any contact, according to a case worker.

“I know they [social workers] tried to contact the family but she didn’t want to do that,” said Joni Weed a volunteer organizer for St. John’s Episcopal Church, which is one of the valley’s largest resources for people in need.

“What I know is that she doesn’t want to leave but would be better off if she left,” Weed said.

Another person who has assisted Hill said she has “a lot of pretty significant mental health issues.“

Still, others happily welcome Hill as the valley’s most unorthodox resident.

“She’s another part of the tapestry that makes our community so unique,”  Petroff said.

Photos of Ms. Hill by Derek Diluzio

PERMALINK:
Ms. Hill's way | Planet JH News Article: Cover Stories

Reader Comments

Nicely written article.
Stacey Breidenstein

Fantastic Article. This will no doubt, be one of the most read stories this paper has published. While Ms. Hill has always greeted me outside Hard Drive, I am thankful to have learned more about her. Further, I can attest to the kindness both Ruth Ann and Mark have shown her. Good people. Greg Robinson, Jackson
Greg Robinson

Great story! This is why I read this little rag
Tw

Oh my yes, what a charming story. A homeless mentally ill female living on the streets. Her outbursts of profanities and other turbulent behavior (including assaults) is so "quaint". I know I find it so touching when she goes on a tirade of "F-Bombs" and racial epithets in public, often in view of familes with children. Won't it be "unique" someday when her frozen corpse is discovered under the bridge, maybe by a child. Wonderful story.
cantbelieveit

can'tbelieveit.... there are an estimated 744,000 homeless people in the United States. We have ONE in our community and you can't handle it. Open your eyes to how other people live and realize that not everyone can afford home. Count your blessings that you are not homeless, and as Ms. Hill might say... go fuck yourself.
dealwithit

Dealwithit, homelessness is a horrible problem in our country. A staggering number of the homeless are mentally ill. Not ill enought to warrant housing and treating them, though. It's a serious break-down in our mental health system. Homelessness it not the source of my disdain. But liberal glorification of how "unique" this particular person is just plain sad. To turn her into an object of curiosity is pathetic. ONE homeless person in Jackson?! You are either extremely naive or blind. One can't blame Ms. Hill for her actions. She is ill. The blame falls on our mental health system. The line between being sick enough to warrant treatment and the rights of an individual to choose how they live is very grey. And yes, some do choose to live like that. Should Ms. Hill CHOOSE to live in another area there would be housing opportunities available. And yes, dealiwithit, you are quite classy yourself.
cantbelieveit

I once gave the "bag lady" a taco at Gorditos and on one other occasion chipped in to buy her pizza bar at Pizza Hut. She is all class and would do well on cash money records with some of her awesome racist and inappropriate outbursts. Some day I would love to read and publish some of her written works.
4d Whomper

i think it s funny how cantbelieve it took such a strongly opposed stance on this article and after being called out on it by dealwithit went full reversal just so they didn t look like such an a hole.
amused

Full reversal?! I don't think so. To romanticise the issue of homelessless and mental illness is sickening. Typical liberal foolishness to say how charming and interesting an obviously mentally ill individual is. Anyone who thinks having the mentally ill and/or homeless wandering our streets adds "character" to a community is just plain asinine.
cantbelieveit

Who's to say who is mentally ill and who isn't. Ms. Hill is more interesting then most folks in town, if that is mental illness then give me more of it.
me

hmmmmmmm... in the paper it says something like, "Marion Hill is the name of this community’s most recognizable homeless resident, but few know her story." unfortunately, we still don't know much of her story. we learned she came from Texas eight or nine years ago, that she just turned 49, and that she has uncles that are mountains. But that's about it. bummer.
GalaxyChicken

cantbelieveit makes valid points. The glorification of a mentally ill individual and her lifestyle is indeed disturbing. dealwithit's "go f...yourself", 4d Whomper's dream of cashing in on Hill, and me's romanticised vision of homelessness and mental illness sum up the attacks on cantbelieve it. He holds a mirror up to this issue and his critics, and they don't like what they see.
little saganaga

first of all i enjoyed the article more than anything else i've ever read in the planet. second i didn't feel that it romanticized homelessness, glorified mental illness, or objectified or objectified ms. hill. i did feel that the article asked questions which a lot of people in this town have wondered themselves. unfortunately it left most of those and more unanswered. @ cantbelieveit: i think that your initial comment sounded hateful of the fact that someone chose to write a people piece on a homeless lady and that's probably why you you were criticized. in your second post you wrote: "One can't blame Ms. Hill for her actions. She is ill." yet this was after you made a point of calling out on her known faults in your first post. also if you don't count the handful of transients that pass through our town each summer and spend a few nights at the mission than yeah there is pretty much just the one homeless person. oh and can you please explain this statement: "Should Ms. Hill CHOOSE to live in another area there would be housing opportunities available."? i wonder if the hundreds of thousands of homeless people across this country know about these housing opportunities. i bet if they did they might not be so homeless. @ little saganaga: the only valid point cantbelieveit made is that there are a whole lot of homeless people in this country which is exactly what the person before them said.
nathan

I find it hard to define homeless. There are many people in this town who are homeless even though it might look otherwise. My "home" existed a long time ago, it has since been sold and all the inhabitants have moved on. I do pay rent at a place so there's a roof over my head and walls keeping me in. I don't see Ms. Hill's situation as much different except that she's found a way around that annoying RENT thing. Many people are here in Jackson because HOME wasn't enough for them. Ms. Hill's lives outside of a car and house and that's all. She's not so different.
me

As far as the mental illness thing goes, I've yet to meet what I would call a sane human being, and I've met a lot of people.
me

Ms. Hill's outbursts are not her fault. That doesn't mean they are acceptible or entertaining in any way. I should have said housing MAY be available. I came from a large metropolitan area where we had several agencies helping the mentally ill. There were numerous shelters and other options available. Many flat out refused the help. She chooses to stay in a town where even those that work for a living can barely afford to live. By CHOOSING to stay here she makes her life much tougher. But then again, I'm not sure she makes rational decisions. My bottom line is her lifestyle and behavior is unfortunate, not entertaining.
cantbelieveit

She is very entertaining!!!!
Mei

Shame on Mei for the callous, unsophisticated, and immature remark. Do you think Ms. Hill does not suffer with her condition? Entertaining indeed! It's very sad when the suffering and infirmity of others is found "entertaining".
little saganaga

She doesn't suffer. I SUFFER from being around all the bore-me-to-death conformists in this town who drive around in their super boring cars, saying poor-baby to all the individuals. She suffers because whY?
mei

Let me guess: Ms. Hill suffers because her Cell phone, computer, and car aren't as nice as yours is that it? She suffers because her personality is different then yours is that it? Everyone who isn't exactly like you must be suffering right? I won't be taking any lessons from you on how to be mature, sensitive, and sophisticated, OK?
mei

Ms. Hill suffers because her condition prevents her from having close, meaningful and emotional bonds and interactions with other human beings. Not that many 'normal' people don't suffer for the same reasons, but for the mentally ill, it's acute.
little saganaga

You assume too much. What makes you think I don't have a deep meaningful emotional bond with Marion. I find Ms. Hill to be one of the few people I interact with who is meaningful and fun. She makes me smile, which is more then I can say for the rest of the drones in this town. I would say that Ms. Hill also has a deep emotional bond with you, which would be the only rational explanation for you coming on the internet to chat about her. Perhaps she's faking the things that you call mental illness so you'll reach out and form the only meaningful connection in your life.
Mei

I'm sorry mei, but I don't believe you. I think you've convinced yourself that the reason there are so few people that you "interact with who is meaningful and fun" for you is that everyone else has a problem. Yes, they're all either "bore-me-to-death conformists" or "drones". I can only suggest you take a hard look at yourself, be humble, and stop blaming others for your alienation.
little saganaga

I'm not alienated, Hell I'm surrounded by people I have close ties with, I'm very easy to get along with. I blame others for being boring.
mei

How quaint, Lets all pitch in and charter busses and fill them with the mentaly ill homeless from Portland and San Francisco,Lets bring them to Jackson Hole and glorify them with penn. I`m sure the illegal aliens could use a break from all the attention.
poli

See what you've done, Planet?? You've gone and become vital again. Lo, these past many months, I have felt as if I have been watching the slow, seemingly endless passing away of a once prominent local news source. Week after week, boring articles on largely unknown, passably talented artists and musicians, complete with bland cover artwork, and a new, bland nameplate, JH Weekly (sorry, you've always been the Planet, and the Planet you will remain). And, then BAM! Weds., 09/09/09 and it all changed. Back to a sharp, crisp, full-bleed cover photo with eye-catching artwork, inviting us to an article that talks about something we've all wondered about. Our curiosity piqued, we weren't disappointed. Just like the old days!! Kudos to Mary, Matt, and especially Ben for a terrific piece on an all too visible reminder in our community of important issues, homelessness and mental health. Don't believe me? Just look at the comments above. Some well-thought out, some petty, some ignorant, but people are talking! What's that number one rule of public relations that could be applied to its distant cousin, news reporting, and response thereto: "I don't care what they (the public) are sayin', as long as they're sayin' something". As opposed to GalaxyChicken, I learned a lot. More like it, please!
Anonyholic II

I know that she has one thing figured out. The only way she is leaving is if she has a round-trip ticket. Amen to that!
skiguy

It is interesting how an author can use words in such a way ... good job! An writer with Ben's skill might even be able to make Bush, Cheney or Obama look like they were good people! jk - not possible. I am proud of Ben for keeping quite the love interest aspect that seems to be shaping up. It is proper to respect Capt Bob and Ms Hill's privacy.
Rumorsmyth

I think BEN is a fabulous writer. The way he captures the triviality of being poor. Ben, you've made me think about my priorities. Usually this paper sucks until we get an article from the mustachioed restaurant reviewer. Keep up the good work Ben. I'm suprised the substandard editor let this one get through. I'm not giving up on the paper yet.
Christian the Marine

GalaxyChicken strikes again!
js

Galaxy Chicken is an idiot.
jojo1013

I have lived here my entire life. I was not raised in a "wealthy" home, but then again as an American, especially in Jackson Hole, wealth is subject to perspective. I know no one will probably read this, so I'll say what & feel. I have been an angry atheist my whole life. As I aged I became more agnostic, then, finally I am now becoming a Catholic. I have been fortunate enough to travel the world, go to college, take religion classes & psychology, was raised with philosophy, and have seen almost all of the states of our great nation. All I have to say is that Mrs. Hill, is just one person. A human being who lives where we all live. She is here maybe for a reason. Maybe not. How we live our lives & treat someone like her is what matters, not our personal opinions about her. Although I read all the comments, and in many ways every person had a valid point. I guess that I want to say is that I had an experience with her, & I am grateful for her, & glad that she's here, no matter how she acts or what she says. We should all be loving & kind to each other, and defend true human virtues like, life, love, honesty, democracy, freedom, & our ability as humans to reach our higher selves. I know this all probably sounds corny, but I don't really care- I mean it, & that's what Mrs. Hill did for me when I helped her out. I love her and I can only hope that one day, we can all love each other as well...
Born n'raised



Leave a Comment


Write a Letter to the Editor
Please limit your letter to 300 words, sign it and give us the name of your town.

Sunday, March 14
TODAY'S EVENTS
Outdoors
National Elk Refuge Sleigh Rides
10:00 AM to 4:00 PM
National Elk Refuge
Classes & Lectures
Feature Creature Naturalist Series
11:00 AM to 11:15 AM
Jackson Hole & Greater Yellowstone Visitor Center, 532 N. Cache Street in Jackson.
Outdoors
Wildlife Caravan
1:30 PM
Elk Refuge
Music
Bob Greenspan
4:00 PM to 8:00 PM
in the Four Seasons Lobby Lounge.
Film
Winter Film Series:Swamp Troop
2:00 PM
Museum of Wildlife Art
Music
Lukas Nelson and the Promise of the Real
8:30 PM
in the Trap Bar at Grand Targhee Resort.
Sports & Recreation
Parks and Recreation
Recreation Center
Classes & Lectures
Israel's Ecology & Wildlife
5:00 PM
Snow King Resort
View All Events
planet polls
Main Poll
Are coming changes in the state legislative body going to make a difference?



Total of voters : 7