Opinion

Protest needed "R" rating

Wednesday, August 15, 2007

By Mary Grossman

Our town is reeling following Saturday’s war protest. I’m sure you’ve heard: Coffee shops are abuzz and local blogs are on fire about the protest. The Planet’s Web server crashed when our video of the protest was linked on DrudgeReport.com, and even Matt Drudge himself talked about the protest on his Sunday radio show. The protest made big news; mission accomplished for the event participants.

I love a good protest. And forgive me for sounding brazenly patriotic, but I’m proud to live in a country where folks are able to gather and express their opposition to the government without fear of retribution.

That said, I’d like to offer my comments about the appropriateness of children attending this particular demonstration. I admit I have a personal bias: I don’t think Cheney is a bad guy. But this editorial isn’t about Cheney; it’s about what we are teaching our children about civil public discourse and respect for our fellow human beings.

l looked at the images of the protesters, images that included young children, noosing and toppling an effigy of VP Cheney, kicking and stomping its head, all the while people cheer in support. Afterwards some children pounced on it like a piñata (perhaps they thought it was full of candy).

I was left speechless and sad, disturbed by the surreal images of our children laughing in the face of such a vicious personal attack. Frankly, I was shocked at the level of disrespect displayed by members of this community.

For young children, taking part in this brutal dramatization – the destruction of the likeness of someone you disagree with – is, in my opinion, as bad as letting them play violent video games. In fact, this form of insidious fascism may be worse. What’s the message here? Destroy anyone you disagree with. War and foreign policy are complex issues, unsuitable for young children. I shudder to think how a 7-year-old interpreted the day’s intense imagery and speeches.

But to be fair, I imagine how I would react if this were a protest I were attending. How would I feel if my peers threw a noose around an effigy of Nancy Pelosi and dragged it behind a car? Embarrassed and ashamed, I suppose, especially in front of my kids.

It is an unfortunate reality that personalities, rather than issues, have become the centerpiece of political debate and more Americans are choosing to opt out of rational discussion. Parents need to resist this trend, which played out here this weekend, and instead provide examples of levelheaded discourse.

Let’s face it: Tempers are flaring these days, and parents from all political perspectives must keep their cool. Go ahead, put on your anti-Cheney sandwich board and march until your feet are raw – but leave the kids at home.
PERMALINK:
Protest needed "R" rating | Planet JH News Article: Editorial

Reader Comments

It is too bad that so much time is spent preaching hate. It was nice to see notable Wyoming Democrat leaders, Gov. Dave and Amb. Sullivan to a name a couple, chose not to attend this day's hate activities. Too bad Rep. Pete Jorgenson decided to give this event credibility for their stand. I hope the people of Teton County will stand up and vote him out at the next election! Hate has no place in Wyoming and the electorate should speak loud and clear about it.
Sad Cowboy

Civil public discourse and respect for our fellow human beings? A great and much needed Christian ethos, indeed. But strangely superficial and hollow from this discordant messenger who hardly practices what she believes she preaches. Oh, Mary how quickly you forget what ill-will you have sown behind the scenes with your own vicious bile and personal attacks. Be not the first to accuse others of casting stones, fair lady.
Et tu, Brute?

I have to admit that I was not surprised by the viciousness of the protest. Having only lived here about 2 years, I find that the people complaining about loss of their constitutional rights all too willing to vilify a person if they choose not to subscribe to the same opinion. I am happy to see that only a handful of kooks acted so viciously and that it is not an example of the greater community. If you don't like the war, vote the people out of office that supported it - Clinton, Kerry, Pelosi, etc. They not only voted to go there in the first place, but also voted to fund it this past spring after they were voted into office with a mandate to end the war! Oh, by the way - I will no longer go to Shades or use any other business service in which their employees act so shamefully.
Common Man

Anyone who thinks patriots tearing down an effigy of Cheney is somehow un-American, are likely the same dummies who believe the toppling of Saddam's statue in Baghdad in 2003 was not a military public relations/psych-ops stunt, but a spontaneous act of celebration by young local Iraqis aided by conveniently located U.S. military personnel.
UncleScam

To all apologists for America’s present anti-Constitutional regime and those too self-serious and too obtuse to realize they’ve been had by the protesters, including the unthinking reactionaries who chastise the protestors for corrupting children while tearing down Cheney’s effigy, this is for you: Your outrage and indignation, arising as it does from your anal, circumscribed, and reactionary sentiments—-ill-formed as they are by false notions of superiority promoted by the most fanatical and most servile of the unpatriotic and increasingly isolated right-wing—-at the protestors’ act of pure political theatre is as stunning as it is entertaining. How did you miss the protest organizers’ ham-fisted scheme to generate publicity and satirize the public relations, psych-ops stunt perpetuated by the U.S. military? Maybe you did not know Uncle Sam had to ship in young Iraqis as props during the staged pull down of Saddam’s statue in Baghdad? How has all this delicious irony been so obviously lost on you? Nonetheless, by wading into this counter-psych-ops fray, Scarlett and Grossman have elevated this small band of protesters public relation’s victory into an even greater coup. And what is equally lost in all their self-revealing and serving comments is any insight into their own rank hypocrisy. What Mary Grossman fails to mention in her weak-kneed OP-Ed is that her for-profit only product, The Planet, benefited enormously from this voluntary, non-profit protest by capturing the demonstrators on video and being the first to publish the story in both text and video form on-line. Given the opportunity to contain dissemination of her so-called “surreal,” “vicious” and “disrespectful” images —- both before and after Matt Drudge picked up the story on his “Drugereport.com” -– Grossman opted to prostitute all the increased attention and traffic for personal gain. And in the process, she is delivering for her advertisers who put food on her family’s table a bonanza of exposure. It is clear as a bell that Grossman, via her on-line asset "Planetjh.com", put commerce over her newfound and highly dubious moral standards. It is she, not the protesters, who is most putting kids at risk by continuing to expose countless children —- and the otherwise impressionable and radical souls around the globe -— each day the story and video plays on her Web site. Meanwhile, Bill Scarlett, who while reproaching the marchers and protesters forgets to also decry the Planet’s crass commercialism, profiteering and collaboration with the enemy, is equally endorsing the Planet’s endangerment of our troops. And by doing so, he has called into question his credentials as a clear-thinking Republican and American. Additionally, the Planet’s trafficking in these images that both Scarlett and Grossman have given their stamp to, either explicitly or implicitly, have also neutralized any high-minded homilies about preserving the public interest and denouncing the manner in which the protestors’ attempted to rightfully redress grievances against a high government official. Their flawed disapproval exemplifies their inability to separate reality from fantasy. Further, those who condemn the pantomime of tearing down Cheney’s effigy are likely too dense and just gullible enough to question whether the tearing down of Saddam’s stature in 2003 was not also stagecraft for their uncritical domestic consumption. Beyond their blindness to the obvious and already well-documented, their ignorance of the basis for the well-founded charge that protest directed at such a high official representative of the United States’ government as Richard Cheney is justified for his willful, repeated and with reckless disregard for his many transgressions under Title 18, code 371 of the U.S. code. Scarlett, who has compromised his normal political smarts by behaving like an obedient pit bull, opts to defend Cheney: a fellow Republican who polls show the majority of decent and forward-thinking fellow Republicans and social conservatives are abandoning in droves. If even not proven a criminal in a court of law or via Congress, Cheney has nonetheless unpatriotically and needlessly marched to their deaths nearly 4,000 Americans and has the blood of thousands more innocent Iraqi men, women and children on his hands. Those who continue to support Cheney’s senseless and bloodthirsty campaign -— based on documented falsehoods, fraud, lies, half-truths, deliberately misleading statements and disinformation emanating from his federal office and public remarks —- are too callow to do their own thinking and homework and are thus stubbornly stuck on the wrong side of history. Aside from the protesters display of simulated revolt to illustrate the true violence to both humanity and the Constitution that the effigy’s likeness represents, have either Scarlett or Grossman shielded their own children from the psychologically damaging results of overexposure to news images of war or their own mindless repetition of right-wing talking points approving in private the obscenity of championing this unjust aggression? We know Cheney and Bush and the rest of this administration have conspired to defraud the Congress and the American people, in violation of federal statutes, because it has already been exhibited by the Senate’s Select Committee on Intelligence, in their September release of a report now available on line, signed by Republicans and Democrats, showing the White House manufactured a nexus between Saddam and 9/11. Scarlett’s support and defense for such a corrupt regime and denouncement of patriotic Americans who would dare to oppose it demonstrates his immaturity to inspire a much-needed Republican Renaissance to save his sinking party. And Grossman’s blind allegiance to those who would march brave men and women into certain and unnecessary via the massive and deliberate deception of the Congress and the nation, without apology, and her promotion of both sides solely for personal gain proves her personal opinions are as mercenary and shallow as her capacity to vet the claims of her those who inform her statements and news product.
BelleCanto

Mary! Dunno about all that above stuff, but how about dishing on how much exposure your advertisers got off Drudge picking up the story, and why aren't you taking it down if you're so damn worried about how these images affect kids? Good job, girl!
InURire



Leave a Comment


Thursday, August 28, 2008
TODAY'S EVENTS
Health & Fitness
Affordable Community Acupuncture
4:00 PM to 7:00 PM
at the Wilson Acupuncture & Healing Arts Center in the Aspens.
Kids & Families
Toddler Gym
9:30 AM to 12:00 PM
at the Recreation Center.
Kids & Families
Toddler Club
8:30 AM to 12:00 PM
at the Recreation Center.
Sports & Recreation
Lunch Hour Basketball
12:00 PM to 2:00 PM
at the Recreation Center.
Music
Phil Round performs
6:30 PM to 9:30 PM
in the double fireplace lobby of the Amangani Hotel atop East Gros Ventre Butte.
Music
Keith Phillips & Bill Plummer play jazz
6:30 PM to 9:30 PM
every Thursday in the Teton Pines Dining Room, off of Teton Village Road.
Music
Steam Powered Airplane plays bluegrass
10:00 PM
every Thursday at the Virginian Saloon.
Community
Walking Tours of Historic Downtown
10:30 AM to 11:30 AM
in Jackson.
Music
Mike Thunder and Vert One spin tunes
10:00 PM
every Thursday at Town Square Tavern.
Music
Disco Night with Andre
10:00 PM
every Thursday at the Stagecoach Bar in Wilson.
Classes & Lectures
Adult English Class Registration
8:00 AM to 8:00 PM
at the Teton Literacy Program, 1715 High School Road.
Kids & Families
Wonder-filled Toddler Times
in the Storytime Room at the Library.
Music
Karaoke every Thursday at
9:00 PM
at the Mangy Moose in Teton Village.
Music
Thomas Michael plays country at
9:00 PM
at the Million Dollar Cowboy Bar.
Classes & Lectures
Adult Spanish Class Registration
8:00 AM to 8:00 PM
at the Teton Literacy Program, 1715 High School Rd.
Community
Habitat for Humanity welcomes volunteers
at the Build Site.
Health & Fitness
Yoga
8:00 AM to 9:15 AM
at the Recreation Center.
Health & Fitness
Yoga Class
12:10 PM to 1:00 PM
at the Recreation Center.
Sports & Recreation
Co-ed Kickball League
5:30 PM to 8:30 PM
at the Mateosky/Snow King Fields.
Community
Chamber Mixer
5:30 PM to 7:30 PM
at Wyoming Title & Escrow, 211 East Broadway.
Community
JH Jewish Community's Membership Party
6:00 PM
at the Lindsay McCandless Contemporary art gallery, 130 S. Jackson St.
Sports & Recreation
Co-Ed Slowpitch Softball
6:00 PM to 10:00 PM
at Cow Pasture 1 & 2 Fields.
Music
Melvin Seals & JGB with Steve Kimock
6:00 PM to 9:00 PM
for the Music on Main Concert Series, outside in the Driggs City Center Plaza, located at 60 S. Main Street.
Music
Judd Grossman plays folk and rock
6:00 PM to 7:00 PM
in the Four Seasons Lobby Lounge.
Music
Jazz Night
7:00 PM to 10:00 PM
every Thursday in the Granary at Spring Creek Ranch atop East Gros Ventre Butte.
Music
Jazz Night
7:00 PM to 10:00 PM
every Thursday in the Granary at Spring Creek Ranch atop East Gros Ventre Butte.
Theater
“Art” by Yasmina Reza
8:00 PM
in the new Studio Theater at the Center for the Arts.
Theater
“Art” by Yasmina Reza
8:00 PM
in the new Studio Theater at the Center for the Arts.
Music
Fat Albert jams instrumental funk at
10:00 PM
at 43 North.
View All Events
YOUR BLOGS

8/18/2008 | 12:24 AM
Class of 1988 20th Reunion

8/14/2008 | 4:32 PM
1% for the People!!!

planet polls
Main Poll
Do you think wind is/will be an effective source of energy?


Total of voters : 88