Opinion

'This issue is settled.'

Wednesday, October 17, 2007

By Brooke Williams

Bill Blakemore, of ABC News, made the above statement during his talk at last week’s conference on climate change and energy at Teton Village. He was referring to the irrefutable evidence that places the blame for our warming climate on modern humans. What is not yet settled is what we’re going to do about it.

I sensed that there were few, if any, “deniers” - people who acknowledge climate change but insist that the globe is merely in a regular warming period - at the conference, and if there were, they weren’t part of the program. Still, when I asked an ardent and traditional environmentalist friend of mine what he thought of the first night’s session, he answered “it seemed very one-sided.” 

Hearing this shocked me into silence. I am familiar enough with this person to know that his comment had nothing to do with the fact that the deniers weren’t given a voice. Thinking back over the last night’s presentations, I had an epiphany: now that we’ve accepted the fact that we’re responsible for the warming planet, there are no sides to this issue.  Yes, there are many opinions about what can and should be done to slow and reverse the current trends, bu
t no one I heard at the conference believed they had the “silver bullet” that will solve the problem. 

Perhaps my friend was referring to the fact that wind and solar power and other renewable energy technologies didn’t receive the focus that some of the other strategies did, but no one involved seemed to discount renewables as part of the solution.  For me, the idea of ‘sides’ in this issue disappeared last winter during a Jackson event sponsored by Conservation International. This was the first time I heard the term “stabilization wedges.”

The idea comes from Princeton scientists and refers to the graph showing the steep line of increasing carbon emissions over the past 50 years to our current level of eight billion tons per year, which is projected to rise to 16 billion tons by the year 2057. (This is subject of Bill McKibben’s article in this month’s National Geographic). 

Each ‘wedge’ represents one of 15 existing technologies that could flatten the graph by one billion tons of carbon emissions by 2057. Improving the fuel economy of two billion cars is one wedge. Others include increasing the efficiency of buildings by 25 percent, halting all deforestation, and using three times as much nuclear power (one pound of uranium produces as much electricity as 12,000 pounds of coal, without emitting carbon) as we are now.

We need all the wedges.

The most discussed wedges involved coal, which makes sense since Wyoming produces more coal than any other state and that one third of the electricity currently used in America is generated in power plants fueled by Wyoming coal. Best case scenarios regarding renewable energy technology suggest that we’ll be using hydrocarbons to generate electricity for 40-50 more years. 

The conference high points were the discussions of how Wyoming is contributing to the development of ‘wedges’ to capture and store carbon (releasing carbon pollutants underground and not into the air) and to improve the efficiency of coal-fired power plants by 20 percent. If we’re concerned about the more distant future, we should be planning for that day when coal is no longer needed by investing in the technologies that will replace it. Much effort is going toward solving the problem of transporting power generated by Wyoming’s famous wind.

If the climate issue could have become polarized at this conference it would have happened during the last panel discussion. Stephanie Kessler, Wyoming’s representative to the Wilderness Society, sat between the president of an oil company and the head of the mining association. She could have spent her few minutes promoting the virtues of the renewable wedges and criticizing any discussion of nuclear power or solutions involving non-renewable resources.

Instead she reminded us that the huge open spaces and the wild animals are why we’re in Wyoming and she cautioned us to avoid the trap of putting a dollar value on much of what makes this state so attractive.

PERMALINK:
'This issue is settled.' | Planet JH News Article: Left Wing Local

Reader Comments

When the wild guy from Iran says to the UN that the Iranian nuclear issue is closed, and Wild Lives quotes a broadcaster that the global warming "issue is settled", it really means that the speakers dearly wish that the very un-closed/settled issues they're talking about were so, when in fact they're not.
PML



Leave a Comment


Write a Letter to the Editor
Please limit your letter to 300 words, sign it and give us the name of your town.

Saturday, July 04, 2009

Thunder in the Vicinity

59°



Listen to today's news by Jackson Hole Radio.

TODAY'S EVENTS
Community
Volunteer With Habitat for Humanity
9:00 AM to 4:00 PM
call for location info.
Music
DJ Thunder and Just Kenny
10:00 PM
at 43 North.
Art
Wilson Summer Arts and Crafts Fair
9:00 AM to 1:00 PM
on the Banks of Fish Creek at the Fish Creek Center in Wilson.
Music
Pianist Pam Drews Phillips
7:00 PM to 10:00 PM
in the Granary at Spring Creek Ranch atop East Gros Ventre Butte.
Music
Phil Round
6:30 PM to 9:30 PM
in the lobby of Amangani Hotel.
Music
Lost Traveler
9:00 PM
at the Million Dollar Cowboy Bar.
Film
NWMA Summer Film Series
2:00 PM
National Museum of Wildlife Art
Music
DJ Optimal
11:00 PM
at Cutty's.
Music
Bob Greenspan
6:00 PM to 10:00 PM
in the Four Seasons Lobby Lounge.
Music
Cowboy Logic
8:00 PM to 11:30 PM
at the Silver Dollar Bar in the Wort Hotel.
Music
Revolver
9:00 PM
at the Virginian Saloon.
Music
4th of July Parade
10:30 AM
with the Jackson Hole Community Band from the Rodeo Grounds, up Glenwood St. to Broadway and on past Town Square. The band then plays a full concert on the Town Square starting at 11:30 a.m.
Community
Howdy Pardner Parade
10:30 AM
Teton County Fair Ground to The Town Square.
Community
Jackson Hole Kids Games
11:30 AM
St. Johns Episcopal Church.
Community
Fourth of July Fireworks
12:00 PM
At the base of Snow King and in Teton Village.
Music
God Bless America Festival
12:00 PM
at the Knotty Pine in Victor.
Music
Music in the Hole
3:00 PM
outside at Alpine Field.
Music
Music in the Hole
3:00 PM to 7:30 PM
On Alpine Field
Music
Wounded Knee
6:00 PM to 10:00 PM
on the deck at South Side Pub and Pizza.
Sports & Recreation
Jackson Hole Rodeo
8:00 PM
Rodeo Grounds on W Snow King Ave.
Music
Head for the Hills
9:30 PM
at the Mangy Moose in Teton Village.
Music
Bastard Sons of Johnny Cash
10:00 PM
at the Bull Moose Saloon in Alpine.
View All Events
planet polls
Main Poll
Should local government foster public art initiatives?


Total of voters : 95