Opinion

Public Editor: New editor chaperones JH Weekly’s conscience

Wednesday, February 10, 2010

By Mike Bressler

Mary and Matt asked me to be the JH Weekly’s public editor. “Hell yeah,” I said. I thought for a moment then asked, “What is a public editor?” They didn’t seem to know either, but they said The New York Times has one and the Jackson Hole News&Guide doesn’t. Sounds like a good enough reason to me!

To better understand my new job I went to journalists’ number one source – Wikipedia. “The job of the public editor is to supervise the implementation of proper journalism ethics at a newspaper … as a valuable symbol of a high standard of ethics for a newspaper, the firing of a public editor over any criticisms they might have would contradict their purpose.” I’m not sure what they mean by journalism ethics but in this economy, you would have to be an idiot to turn down a job that’s own purpose would be contradicted if they fired you!

Because Jackson is a small town and the JH Weekly is selective in the stories it pursues, and because I can’t resist, I will occasionally write about unique cultural phenomenon observed and reported on by the JH Weekly. Also, because they offer such an easy target and because I always rooted for David over Goliath, I will sporadically cast pearls of journalism morals before the trampling feet of our friendly competitors, the News&Guide. So here are my first observations from the news stories of Feb. 3.

Last week’s “Planet” reported that Fitzgerald’s Bikes are “hosting the first of what could turn into a series of indoor virtual bike races” where “riders can watch themselves compete against their competitors on a big screen television that will simulate a hilly bike race.” This is almost as bad as a heated indoor arena for cowboys! If I may politely inquire, is indoor virtual reality why you moved here from New Jersey?

Ben Cannon’s story told of the tribulations of the Teton Ice Park an “artificial ice-climbing area.” Artificial ice-climbing? I had to check this out. Apparently, the Teton Ice Park offers ice climbing on a 100 by 100 foot cliff in the Grand Targhee Parking lot. The ice is formed with the assistance of a 3000 gallon tanker truck and low flow shower heads. I doubt either the ice or the climbing is artificial, but I do question the fee of $360 for a full day of guiding. In an attempt to rescue any remaining maintain dignity associated with the profession, I would request the word “guide” not be used in conjunction with parking lot ice climbing.

Lastly, is a quote from Christie Koriakin’s story on snowflakes. “(Kenneth) Libbrecht, Professor of Physics and the Physics Department Chair at the California Institute of Technology, has been studying and photographing snowflakes for more than 10 years.” Really? Perhaps this is the one man who could comprehend the meaning of an indoor virtual bike race. JHW

Send your questions, comments, grievances and ideas to the Public Editor, publiceditor@planetjh.com.
PERMALINK:
Public Editor: New editor chaperones JH Weekly’s conscience | Planet JH News Article: Editorial

Reader Comments

let me get this straight... the reason PJH gave for hiring your for this job is because the NYT has one and the NAG doesn't? And then you read a job description on wikipedia, "a journalist's number one source" - LOL, and finally you ponder what could possibly be meant by "journalism ethics." Sounds like they've got the right guy for the job! P.S. - The cowboys in this town are enjoying the Heritage Arena very much, thank you. I'm looking forward to more jabs at other cultural aspects of our community that are marginally clever and not funny.
Tony

"the JH Weekly is selective in the stories it pursues" - can't really argue with that statement. But if you want to compete with the JHN&G, you're going to have to deliver some actual "news".
Reality Bias

Compete with the N&G? Why? Let's hope they don't.
jj

Tony and person to be known as "Reality Bias" - The advantage of a public editor is if you have an issue with JH Weekly, you can now submit it in the form of a question rather than an insult, and Mike will work on an answer. I know it may not be as fun for you, but it may actually build community dialogue and influence content.
MJI, editor

Best of luck.
eyeson jackson

MJI - My issue with this new position isn't the position, but the person you've hired. In this article he admits he didn't even know what a public editor does (of course, hiring someone for a position for which he has know knowledge or experience reflects poorly on your and MG's judgment). He then cites "journalists' number one source" as Wikipedia. Seriously??? Finally, he admits he's "not sure what they mean by journalism ethics." When a big part public editor's job is to judge whether or not the newspaper is acting ethically, shouldn't he at least have some idea of the framework of journalistic ethics? I suppose he could just look that one up on Wikipedia, too...
Tony

You are humorless.
MJI

I guess yer "public editor" has poor delivery, because I didn't know he was trying to be funny. One thing's for sure, though... he's a joke.
Tony

personally, i love how funny JHWeekly is these days. If this rag is heading into the territory of the Onion, hurray. Still not as funny as Circling The Square though.
Old Dirty Bastard



Leave a Comment


Write a Letter to the Editor
Please limit your letter to 300 words, sign it and give us the name of your town.

Wednesday, February 08
TODAY'S EVENTS
Music
Karaoke
9:00 PM
at the Virginian Saloon.
Music
Jackson Hole Jazz Foundation
7:00 PM to 9:00 PM
rehearsal at the Center for the Arts.
Community
Volunteer Day at Habitatv
9:00 AM to 4:30 PM
at Hall Street job site in east Jackson.
Classes & Lectures
Free Weekly Knitting Help!
11:30 AM
Knit on Pearl in Jackson, WY
Community
Teton County Roundtable Program
11:45 AM to 1:00 PM
at the First Interstate Bank’s training room, located at 802 West Broadway.
Music
Liatt Potter & Dan Mihlfeith
5:00 PM to 8:00 PM
in the Lobby Lounge of Four Seasons Resort.
Classes & Lectures
Foreign Policy Series: Cybersecurity
6:00 PM
at County Commissioners Chamber, 200 S. Willow Street.
Music
Plum Tuckered Out
6:30 PM
at Cafe Genevieve.
Music
Plum Tuckered Out
6:30 PM
at Cafe Genevieve.
Music
Live in the Hole: Off Square Theatre
6:30 PM to 7:00 PM
on 89.1 FM, KHOL.
Music
Buol Heslin
7:00 PM to 9:00 PM
at Alpine Wines in Driggs.
Outdoors
Wyoming Native Plant Society Presents
7:00 PM
at Wyoming Game and Fish, 420 N. Cache.
Music
Sweethogs and Swinehearts Ball
9:00 PM
at the Mangy Moose in Teton Village.
View All Events
planet polls
JH Weekly Poll
Who do you think should pay for the health care of Aaron Wallis?



Total of voters : 74