Opinion

Public Editor: Unlawful work

Tuesday, August 31, 2010

By Mike Bressler

Jackson Hole, Wyoming - Matthew Irwin’s editorial last week on illegal workers had, as he claimed, lots of surface area, though not much point. For those raised in the right-to-work Rocky Mountains before the onslaught of urban sophisticates who view manual labor as something dark skinned people do, illegal immigration was not an issue. It wasn’t easy scraping a living off a 60-day tourist season and a few cow ranches. Work ethic was sacred, a virtue no amount of sinning could compromise as slothfulness was a sin no amount of goodness could redeem. (The immigrants we worried about were East Coast hippies. They lay around smoking pot, used food stamps, and if they did get a job, they usually screwed it up.)
 
Of course illegal work is illegal, but illegal is not always black and white. In a JH Weekly interview, the chief of police said he enforced marijuana on a spectrum, the consumer being a very low-level enforcement priority. Who doesn’t set cruise control to at least eight (or more) miles above posted speed limits because the law will let it slide? Using pot or speeding is as illegal as illegal work. On the other side of the spectrum, Wyoming Game and Fish enforce all statutes vigorously, (the bastards). Laws are exactingly or leniently enforced as a reflection of society’s values. It’s not just Jackson. Murder a black man and a white man in Texas and see which crime gets you the death penalty.

As a tradesman, I know many who believe low paying jobs will remain low paying until illegal workers are gone, the available work force reduced. Others sympathize with those who leave their home to offer honest sweat, their only asset. We need to decide if illegal work is like speeding a few miles over the limit, poaching an elk, killing a black man in Texas or a white man, and why?  JHW


PERMALINK:
Public Editor: Unlawful work | Planet JH News Article: Editorial

Reader Comments

I think you should run up to Canada, demand work, social services, citizenship for your kids, free healthcare & a US Resource Center to make the whole process easier.
eyeson jackson

A rational question to ask about 'crime' is "is there a victim - was someone hurt enough to complain?" At that point it can be judged. Given those parameters, the drug laws (especially marijuana), are wrong, and should not be compared to murder and what not.
Mr. Jones

Thank God none is getting hurt from the consumer demand for illegal drugs, or the use of said drugs. I disagree with the idea that the long arm of the law doesn't take the consumer use of drugs very seriously. Local Law Enforcement has so little serious crime to deal with that minor drug cases are often treated like major crimes. Much of the stuff our police focus on isn't given a second thought in big cities. Consumers, however, are the problem. The durg-war deaths in Mexico and here at home are due to consumer demand. As for the whole issue of immigration, it is just another form of class warfare. Poorer Working-class Americans lose.
eyeson jackson

Hate to break the news to Mike, but the vast majority of illegal immigrants from south of the border didn't come here to offer honest sweat. Wake up, dude. Yes, a MINORITY of them are here to attempt to work hard and contribute to our society. The vast majority... ain't. Not sure what bubble you live in, but try moving to a border town/state for 10 years and your eyes may open. This load of BS that illegals from Mexico are coming here illegally just so that they can work hard and pay taxes is the purest form of crap. Most come here for the promise of a better life: and that means leaching off our system.
viewed_valley

viewed_valley: Thanks for responding to my article. I’m a Wyoming boy and am not too familiar with the rest of the country. (If you’re going to pick a bubble, Wyoming ain’t so bad!) My article referred to the immigrants in this area and in the agricultural areas of the state only. I only have my own experience of working in the construction trades locally and seeing immigrants working at various places. (I have no idea which if any are illegal or legal.) I have no statistics to back up my belief, that most are here to work. Do have any local statistics or firsthand experience to about local immigrants not wanting to work? It is not my experience and it would be interesting to know. There is so much anger and resentment on this issue; it can sometime blind either side. I don’t like illegal’s taking our jobs, but the way I was raised makes it hard for me to condemn honest work regardless of skin color, nationality or legal residency. I guess I’m like everyone else-blame my parents!
Mike Bressler

I've been all over border towns and have yet to see the " majority" of immigrants that are looking for a free ride as described by viewed_valley. OOf course, poor people, be they American or not, hard wrokers or not, tend to seek and need more assistance than those that feed off of them--the middle & upper classes. Folks who wait in line to come here legally and work legally and seek citizenship--not just a paycheck--get screwed while we reward illegal immigrants for taking a shortcut.
eyeson jackson



Leave a Comment


Write a Letter to the Editor
Please limit your letter to 300 words, sign it and give us the name of your town.

Wednesday, February 08
TODAY'S EVENTS
Music
Karaoke
9:00 PM
at the Virginian Saloon.
Music
Jackson Hole Jazz Foundation
7:00 PM to 9:00 PM
rehearsal at the Center for the Arts.
Community
Volunteer Day at Habitatv
9:00 AM to 4:30 PM
at Hall Street job site in east Jackson.
Classes & Lectures
Free Weekly Knitting Help!
11:30 AM
Knit on Pearl in Jackson, WY
Community
Teton County Roundtable Program
11:45 AM to 1:00 PM
at the First Interstate Bank’s training room, located at 802 West Broadway.
Music
Liatt Potter & Dan Mihlfeith
5:00 PM to 8:00 PM
in the Lobby Lounge of Four Seasons Resort.
Classes & Lectures
Foreign Policy Series: Cybersecurity
6:00 PM
at County Commissioners Chamber, 200 S. Willow Street.
Music
Plum Tuckered Out
6:30 PM
at Cafe Genevieve.
Music
Plum Tuckered Out
6:30 PM
at Cafe Genevieve.
Music
Live in the Hole: Off Square Theatre
6:30 PM to 7:00 PM
on 89.1 FM, KHOL.
Music
Buol Heslin
7:00 PM to 9:00 PM
at Alpine Wines in Driggs.
Outdoors
Wyoming Native Plant Society Presents
7:00 PM
at Wyoming Game and Fish, 420 N. Cache.
Music
Sweethogs and Swinehearts Ball
9:00 PM
at the Mangy Moose in Teton Village.
View All Events
planet polls
JH Weekly Poll
Who do you think should pay for the health care of Aaron Wallis?



Total of voters : 74